Crosby's

Crosby's Family owned since 1922 - Serving NY & PA 🍕
Your Hometown Convenience Store ⛽
📸: Freshly made pizza, subs, and breakfast items.

Freshly brewed Arabica bean coffee. Everyday values on grocery items. NY and PA Lottery
Fuel
ATM

Lunchtime just hit different—thanks to Crosby’s. 🔥 Warm up with a Pickle Pizza slice or a classic Pepperoni Roll. Either...
16/01/2025

Lunchtime just hit different—thanks to Crosby’s. 🔥 Warm up with a Pickle Pizza slice or a classic Pepperoni Roll. Either way, lunchtime just got better. Stop in today and treat yourself! 🍕🧡

It’s cold outside, but breakfast is hot and ready at Crosby’s! 🧀🔥 Treat yourself to Cheesy Egg Bites or Stuffed Biscuit ...
16/01/2025

It’s cold outside, but breakfast is hot and ready at Crosby’s! 🧀🔥 Treat yourself to Cheesy Egg Bites or Stuffed Biscuit Bites—the perfect way to beat the chill. Get them while they’re still here! ❄️

15/01/2025

Crosby's West Seneca Meatball Pizza Review

We're doing it again, Crosby's fans! Here's your chance to enter for the game happening this Saturday! 🎉 Sign up today f...
14/01/2025

We're doing it again, Crosby's fans! Here's your chance to enter for the game happening this Saturday! 🎉 Sign up today for your shot at winning! 🏆 Don't miss out!

We use cookies to deliver the best possible experience to you. In order to continue using this website, you agree that we may store and access cookies on your device.

14/01/2025
09/01/2025

Calling all Mafia Pizza lovers! 😍 Take advantage while you still can, packed to perfection with mouthwatering toppings. Act fast before it’s gone! 🔥🍴

🚨 GIVEAWAY ALERT! 🚨Sign up for My Crosby's Rewards and enter for a chance to WIN Buffalo Bandits Lacrosse tickets! 🥍🎟✨ H...
07/01/2025

🚨 GIVEAWAY ALERT! 🚨

Sign up for My Crosby's Rewards and enter for a chance to WIN Buffalo Bandits Lacrosse tickets! 🥍🎟

✨ How to Enter:
1️⃣ Sign up for My Crosby's Rewards (it's free!).
2️⃣ That's it – you're in!

📢 No purchase necessary.

Hurry don’t miss out! 🧡🏆

We use cookies to deliver the best possible experience to you. In order to continue using this website, you agree that we may store and access cookies on your device.

Busy morning? We've got you covered! 🍳🥓 Pick up our stuffed biscuit bites or cheesy egg bites while they last. Quick, ea...
07/01/2025

Busy morning? We've got you covered! 🍳🥓 Pick up our stuffed biscuit bites or cheesy egg bites while they last. Quick, easy, and delicious!

🛒Crosby's Convenience, Delivered! 🛒From groceries, snacks, and drinks to gift cards, skip the trip, let us bring it to y...
06/01/2025

🛒Crosby's Convenience, Delivered! 🛒

From groceries, snacks, and drinks to gift cards, skip the trip, let us bring it to you. 🏠

Order online today! 📲

Family owned and operated, serving up delicious fresh pizza, fuel & more to communities in NY & PA. Mobile & Online Ordering available.

03/01/2025

Bahamas Bowl bound! 🏈🎉 We’re thrilled to see UB take the field. We wanted to celebrate their bid with pizza, good vibes, and all the snacks to cheer them on! 🍕💙

Pizza cravings are no problem with Crosbys’ Pepperoni Rolls. 🍕✨ All the flavor, no fuss—ready to grab and go! 🚗🙌 ...
02/01/2025

Pizza cravings are no problem with Crosbys’ Pepperoni Rolls. 🍕✨ All the flavor, no fuss—ready to grab and go! 🚗🙌

Hello, 2025! 🎉 Start the year off right with Crosbys Breakfast Pizza. 🍕 Whether you’re recovering from last night’s fest...
01/01/2025

Hello, 2025! 🎉 Start the year off right with Crosbys Breakfast Pizza. 🍕 Whether you’re recovering from last night’s festivities or just need a break from cooking, we’ve got the perfect slice waiting for you. Grab yours today!

31/12/2024

Ring in the New Year with style (and flavor)! 🍕 Whether you're heading to a party or cozying up at home to watch the ball drop, Crosbys Pizza is here to keep your night delicious. 🍕

🎉 Congrats to our 3,716,000th slice winner—FREE slices for a year! 🍕 Grab a slice, stay tuned, and follow us for more ch...
30/12/2024

🎉 Congrats to our 3,716,000th slice winner—FREE slices for a year! 🍕 Grab a slice, stay tuned, and follow us for more chances to win! 👀✨

Celebration mode: ON! 🎊🏆 Last night’s win deserves a Crosbys sub. Visit your local Crosbys and savor the taste of victor...
30/12/2024

Celebration mode: ON! 🎊🏆 Last night’s win deserves a Crosbys sub. Visit your local Crosbys and savor the taste of victory today!

Family owned and operated, serving up delicious fresh pizza, fuel & more to communities in NY & PA. Mobile & Online Ordering available.

🎄 This Thursday, spend less time cooking and more time enjoying the holiday season! 🍕 Grab our 2 Large Cheese Pizza Deal...
26/12/2024

🎄 This Thursday, spend less time cooking and more time enjoying the holiday season! 🍕 Grab our 2 Large Cheese Pizza Deal to save time, save money, and feed the whole family with ease. 🎉 Great food, better company!

🛍️ The holiday rush just got easier. Crosbys has everything you need to keep the season stress-free. 🎄🎁 Stop by and grab...
24/12/2024

🛍️ The holiday rush just got easier. Crosbys has everything you need to keep the season stress-free. 🎄🎁 Stop by and grab your last-minute essentials today!

Family owned and operated, serving up delicious fresh pizza, fuel & more to communities in NY & PA. Mobile & Online Ordering available.

24/12/2024

Pickle pizzas are disappearing fast! Swing by Crosby’s this Christmas and grab one before someone takes them all....Make your holiday unforgettable (and delicious)!

Address


Telephone

(716) 434-2885

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Crosby's posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Videos

Calling all Mafia Pizza lovers! 😍 Take advantage while you still can, packed to perfection with mouthwatering toppings. Act fast before it’s gone! 🔥🍴 #Crosbys #Munchtime #MafiaSlice #Pizzatime #Delicious

Bahamas Bowl bound! 🏈🎉 We’re thrilled to see UB take the field. We wanted to celebrate their bid with pizza, good vibes, and all the snacks to cheer them on! 🍕💙 #Crosbys #Pizzatime #Football #GoodVibes

Ring in the New Year with style (and flavor)! 🍕 Whether you're heading to a party or cozying up at home to watch the ball drop, Crosbys Pizza is here to keep your night delicious. 🍕 #Crosbys #NYE2025 #Pizzatime #Munchtime #Delicious

Pickle pizzas are disappearing fast! Swing by Crosby’s this Christmas and grab one before someone takes them all....Make your holiday unforgettable (and delicious)! #Crosbys #PicklePizza #Munchtime #Christmas #Delicious

✨ Forget the cookies—Santa deserves a slice of Crosby’s pizza instead! 🍕 Even our youngest pizza lovers know where the real holiday magic happens. Come grab yours today and treat yo’ self! 😉 #Crosbys #Pizza #Holidays #Delicious #Gifts

Support our MVP! 🏆Stop by your local Crosby’s and pick up an MVP Box. Treat yourself while making a difference for a great cause! #MVP #Crosbys #Pizzatime #Patriciaallenfund #OCH #Community

Primetime is back! 🏈🔥 Head to your local Crosby's and snag your Primetime deal—just in time for the big game!🍕🍗 #Primetime #Crosbys #Munchtime #Bills #Football

Pickle Pizza
Pickle Pizza

The wait is over—Pickle Pizza is here! 🥒🍕 Run, don’t walk, to Crosby’s and grab a slice (or a whole pie) today. It's a dill-icious treat you’ve gotta try! 😋 Available December 1st, 2024 #PicklePizza #Pizzatime #Crosbys #Munchtime #Delicious

"Celebrate National Pickle Day like no other! 🥒🍕Our Pickle Pizza is coming soon so get ready for a new favorite!" #Crosbys #Pizzatime #Delicious #Pickles #PickleDay

Fuel up & enjoy a free treat! 🚗⛽️ When you fill up with 10+ gallons at Crosbys, grab a free 2-liter Coke product! Don’t wait—stop by and take advantage of this sweet deal! 🍂🥤 #Crosbys #Free #Morningfuel #Fuel #Savings

Rise and shine with Crosby's! 🌞 Start your day off with a delicious breakfast sandwich or add a little spice to your morning with a crispy chicken sandwich. We’ve got just what you need to step up your day! 🍳🐔 #Crosbys #Munchtime #Morningfuel #Delicious #LTO

Help us reach $100K for Oishei Children’s Hospital! 🚗❤️Let’s rally together and make every gallon matter! #Crosbys #Fuel #OCH #Community #Pizza

Shortcuts

  • Address
  • Telephone
  • Alerts
  • Contact The Business
  • Videos
  • Claim ownership or report listing

  • Want your business to be the top-listed Convenience Store?

Share

Company History

Crosby's Stores had its beginnings as a dairy farm founded in 1902 by E. S. O'Mara. E. S. grew the farm and by 1940 opened his first dairy bar in a newly constructed milk plant. In 1965, the O'Mara Dairy Farm merged with Crosby Dairy. On July 1st, 1966, Crosby Dairy opened its first store in Little Valley, New York. Our first gas pump opened in 1972, a single bay gas station acquired from the Kendall Refining Corporation located in Bradford. By 1996 we developed a food service program that continues to be the focus of our future vision today. In 2006, Crosby's Stores was acquired by Reid Stores, of Lockport, NY, where it was merged with K&K Foods and the chain was re branded Crosby's Stores. Most of all, along the way, we emphasized the importance of customer service. Serving rural communities with our roots as a family dairy business, we strive to be the hometown presence with a personal touch for each and every customer. That's why we've made our tagline "Add a Smile to your day!"